5 facts about the state of the news media in 2017
Every year since 2004, Pew Research Center has issued an annual assessment of the state of the news media that tracks key audience and economic indicators for a variety of sectors within the U.S. news media industry. Here are the key findings for 2017:
1The audience for nearly every major sector of the U.S. news media fell in 2017 – with the only exception being radio. The evening audience for both local and network TV news declined 7%, while for cable it fell 12%, according to comScore TV Essentials® and StationView Essentials® data. Meanwhile, digital-native news sites’ audiences declined by 5% in terms of monthly unique visitors in 2017, according to comScore Media Metrix Multi-platform data. And the circulation for U.S. daily newspapers, whose audience has been steadily declining for several decades, fell by 11% last year, according to an analysis of data from the Alliance for Audited Media (AAM).
Radio was the only sector studied that did not show an audience decline, by several measures. The overall audience for terrestrial radio – which includes all formats, not just news – has been around 90% for at least the past nine years, according to Nielsen Media Research data published by the Radio Advertising Bureau that looked at Americans ages 12 and older who listen in a given week. The audience for programming from NPR and Public Radio International (PRI) also held steady in 2017, at 30 million and 9 million average weekly listeners respectively, according to data from those public broadcasters, while the audience for programming from American Public Media (APM) rose 7% in 2017. The audience for podcasting has grown over the past decade, with 17% of Americans 12 and older now listening to a podcast in the past week, according to Edison Research and Triton Digital. (Again, this includes any type of programming, not just news.)
2The “post-election slump” for TV viewership explains audience declines for cable and local TV – but not network. The 2016 election was one that many Americans followed closely, and in the past, TV news has generally seen its audience fall off after election years. Most notably, the prime-time audience for cable news fell 18% in 2013 and 9% in 2009, which is in line with the 12% decline in 2017. The post-election change in the early evening local TV news audience has ranged from a decrease of 8% to an increase of 3% over the past four post-election years, putting the 7% decline in 2017 at the low end but still within the normal range. However, network TV’s decline in 2017 was unusual, as its audience has been relatively steady after election years. (There has been no post-election effect for newspapers and radio in recent years, and the Center only began tracking the digital audience in 2014.)
3Cable networks stand out for revenue growth, and network news’ economic picture was stable. Revenue for cable news continued to rise, up by 10% in 2017, according to SNL Kagan estimates. Advertiser expenditures for network TV news were steady, according to estimates from Kantar Media. Radio, whose audience was largely steady, similarly held its own when it came to revenue, according to an analysis of MEDIA Access Pro & BIA Advisory Services data. But newspapers continued to see their revenue decline with ad revenue falling 10%, according to an analysis of SEC filings by publicly-traded newspaper companies, and local TV news revenue was lower both than 2016 and slightly lower than for other recent off-election years (2013 and 2015), according to an analysis of MEDIA Access Pro & BIA Advisory Services data.
These declines in revenue could potentially lead to reductions in newsroom staffing and resources for newsgathering. Newsroom employment has already dropped by nearly a quarter in less than 10 years, with the greatest decline at newspapers, according to a Pew Research Center analysis. Newspapers have also seen a consistent decline in revenue over the same period.
4Digital advertising revenue continues to grow, but little of it benefits news organizations. Total digital advertising revenue has jumped 25% in 2017 across all types of digital outlets, not just news, according to eMarketer. This has been especially true of mobile advertising revenue, which totaled $61 billion in 2017, roughly equal to the total amount of digital advertising revenue just two years prior, in 2015 ($60 billion) – and which goes hand in hand with Americans’ increased use of mobile for news. However, news organizations seem to share little in this bonanza – 52% of all digital display advertising revenue goes to just two companies: Facebook and Google.
5Hispanic media also experienced audience declines. TV news audiences for both Telemundo and Univison, the two largest Hispanic television news networks in the U.S., fell across the board, in all major time slots for both their national and local news broadcasts. Newspaper circulation declined by at least 18% for the three daily Hispanic papers with 2017 data, though circulation at weekly Hispanic newspapers was about even. Univision’s revenue, however, was nearly the same as in 2016.
Note: As the audience for online news continues to gain on traditional platforms, according to our survey work, it is important to note that some of the data above for different sectors do not fully include digital audience. The TV data, for example, measure live viewership so do not include the audience for those networks’ online videos and articles, and even though website audience metrics are available for these six networks, there is no clear measure that indicates how much of that audience is the same or different from the television audience. And while newspaper circulation measures both digital and print, some of the largest U.S. newspapers do not fully report their digital circulation to AAM. However, even with the most liberal estimate of this missing digital audience, digital gains would not make up for print declines. The one “pure digital” metric we have – traffic to digital-native news sites – showed a decline in 2017.
Michael Barthel is a research associate focusing on journalism research at Pew Research Center.