April 6, 2015

From Twitter to Instagram, a different #Ferguson conversation

On social media, hashtags have long been used as a shorthand way of organizing a conversation around an event or topic. One widely used hashtag over the past year is #Ferguson, which started after the police shooting of an unarmed black man in Ferguson, Mo., and has since become a kind of connective tissue for the massive number of social media posts about the event and what it has come to represent.

#Ferguson Used Differently on Twitter and InstagramIn a new analysis of the #Ferguson hashtag on Twitter and Instagram, Pew Research Center has found some striking differences between the two social media platforms in how people use the hashtag and direct the conversation.

On Twitter, which quickly became a source of information about the Michael Brown shooting last August, usage of the hashtag #Ferguson has primarily focused on the discussion about Brown, the ensuing protests and the authorities’ response.

But on Instagram – a growing photo-sharing site with roughly the same number of users as Twitter – the usage is much broader. There, the hashtag has been employed less as a reference to the events in Missouri, and more often as a way for people to discuss or reference issues such as race, police brutality and politics. In other words, the content and context a user gets from tracking the #Ferguson hashtag on Instagram is quite different from on Twitter.

For example, 86% of the Twitter conversation with that hashtag was directly related to the news in Ferguson, such as the community protests, the U.S. Department of Justice report or the city’s police department.

And unlike on Twitter, a majority (62%) of the Instagram posts studied were not directly about the events of Ferguson and their aftermath, but instead used the hashtag to make a connection between the subject of the post and the Ferguson saga. By contrast, 38% were posts where Ferguson was the subject.

To analyze #Ferguson on Twitter and Instagram, we utilized two different methods. For Twitter, researchers used the social media analytics tool from Crimson Hexagon to conduct computer coding of all public tweets starting on March 3, 2015, when new developments brought Ferguson back into the headlines, and ending on March 25. Instagram is a less mature and less studied platform than Twitter, and there are fewer tools for analyzing its content. To study Instagram, researchers pulled publicly available posts directly from the site’s API (application program interface) and performed human coding of a random sample of posts appearing during the same period.

Tweet by @Channel4News on March 4, 2015.Twitter analysis

From March 3, the day before the Justice Department released its report on the Ferguson Police Department and the events surrounding the shooting, to March 25, about 650,000 tweets included the hashtag #Ferguson. The majority of those were focused on happenings either in Ferguson or directly related to Ferguson.

For example, the British network Channel 4 News shared this tweet regarding one of the main conclusions of the DOJ report: “@TheJusticeDept clears officer Darren Wilson of civil rights violations in Mike Brown shooting in #Ferguson.”

FT_15.04.06_fergusonCoopFoggJames Cooper, aka @CoopFogg, shared information about ongoing meetings. “#Ferguson city council voted to hold today’s meeting in private,” he wrote to his followers on March 9.

Just 14% of the conversation with the hashtag was focused on events located elsewhere. There, Twitter users included the hashtag when commenting on other incidents that involved alleged police brutality – such as the shooting death of 19-year-old Tony Robinson by a police officer in Madison, Wis.

Focusing on Robinson, @VSouza_STL tweeted, “#TonyRobinson: your life mattered—-and it still does. I’m sorry they murdered you. You will not be forgotten. #BlackLivesMatter #Ferguson.”

FT_15.04.06_fergusonJedudecoConnecting several different racially charged incidents, @jedudeco posted, “#Oklahoma #SAE PROVES #Ferguson IS NOT AN EXCEPTION. #RacismExists #GOP #Selma50 #TrayvonMartin #EricGarner #BlackLivesMatter #lynching.”

Researchers also looked at the Twitter data another way, classifying tweets tagged with #Ferguson as either focused on a specific event (in Ferguson or beyond), or else focused on a broader theme or issue. During the period studied, 71% of the Twitter conversation was focused on a specific current event, while 29% focused on themes.

FT_15.04.06_fergusonESTRAThe portion that was more thematic in nature included references to the protests in general, or issues that have been brought to the forefront because of the situation.

For example, the account of ESTRA, an online radio show, included support for the protesters. “#Ferguson young people be #proud of your #work. Continue waking up America. #ESTRA #Seattle #BlackVoices.”

Annie Shields linked to an article in The Nation and wrote, “It’s Not Just #Ferguson: Cities nationwide are criminalizing black people to pay the bills.”

FT_15.04.06_fergusonRodneyleonInstagram analysis

If someone followed the #Ferguson discussion on Instagram, however, they would have discovered a far different conversation. First, there were far fewer public posts over the same time period (March 3-25), about 8,400, and the hashtagged conversation was more thematic in nature and less focused on events occurring on the ground in Ferguson.

The architect of the U.N. slavery memorial, Rodney Leon, posted a close-up picture of the structure, which was to be unveiled in New York on March 25, and included #Ferguson to connect the different happenings.

FT_15.04.06_fergusonSpreadingNearly two-thirds (64%) of all the Instagram posts studied were not about specific events, but were focused on themes and ideas around race and the history of civil rights. The other 36% were about specific events, whether tied to Ferguson or elsewhere.

For example, one user posted a picture of Nelson Mandela with the quote, “For to be free is not merely to cast off one’s chains, but to live in a way that respects and enhances the freedom of others.”

Since Instagram gives users more space for text than Twitter, many Instagram posts included a long list of hashtags. Meaning for the author was often conveyed by the connection of those hashtags, rather than an explicit reference to the picture.

FT_15.04.06_fergusonSkubusteveFor instance, skubusteve posted a remembrance of the poet Maya Angelou that included a number of different hashtags such as #BlackLivesMatter, #50Years and #BloodySunday along with #Ferguson.

A number of other theme-oriented posts involved religious images.

One Instagram user, shanderath03ps0n88, posted an image with many religious hashtags such as #GOD. #PRAY and #JESUS, but also included references to current events such as #FERGUSON and #ericgarner.

FT_15.04.06_fergusonShanderathWhile they were less common on Instagram than Twitter, there were still some posts focused on specific events, many of which were tied to the news out of Ferguson. For example, Instagram user authorjmg posted an image of a protest march in Ferguson.

“Here are some amazing moments we shared as the #ItsAGambleProduction Team captured history in the making at the #NationalMarchOnFerguson,” she wrote.

FT_15.04.06_fergusonAuthorjmgConversations on social media, of course, extend further than just the posts containing a hashtag. But hashtags remain a key tool for organizing a flood of information in a complex set of networks such as those on Twitter, Instagram and other sites. Hashtags can also provide an entry point into a topic or news item for a social media user.

The data shown here, while covering a brief window of time, provide a sense of just how different the tagging norms can be on one platform versus another. The data also suggest that a conversation referencing a major news event such as #Ferguson can take on a life of its own, and show up in places far from where it started.

You can see the methodology for this report here.

Topics: Internet Activities, Race and Ethnicity, Social Media

  1. Photo of Paul Hitlin

    is a senior researcher focusing on internet, science and technology at Pew Research Center.

  2. Photo of Jesse Holcomb

    is an associate director of research at Pew Research Center.

Leave a Comment

All comments must follow the Pew Research comment policy and will be moderated before posting.

2 Comments

  1. Shelley1 year ago

    Is anyone writing a book about Ferguson? The social studies department at my high school would like to have their students read about this tragedy.

    Reply
  2. J Adisa1 year ago

    Great stuff (though I suspect your good thinking will get drowned out by people with political axes to grind).

    I have long argued to my colleagues that hashtags ‘function’ differently on Instagram versus Twitter.

    My primary point is that (when used properly)
    – On Twitter, hashtags point to trends whereas
    – On Instagram, hashtags are metadata.

    Practically speaking, on Instagram, the inclusion of a hashtag is expected to describe the contents of the image, whereas on Twitter, the hashtag should associate the tweet with a larger conversation.

    There is bound to be some overlap and blurring of the edges due to users who post the same content on both platforms, but I find that in a broad sampling, the distinction is a sound, defensible one.

    Reply