January 13, 2014

Obama lags his predecessors in recess appointments

32

In his six years in office, Barack Obama has made 32 recess appointments to federal positions.

While recess appointments have long been used by presidents to at least temporarily fill federal positions, they attract the most attention when they are used to install a nominee who might be otherwise blocked by the Senate. One such politically-charged case is before the Supreme Court today and it could result in sharply curtailing recess appointments in the future.

The case is reaching the high court at a time when President Obama has been locked in a bitter fight with Senate Republicans over his nominees, particularly his choices for the judiciary. But while appointments have been a contentious issue during his administration, Obama has resorted to the recess appointment at a far lesser pace than the four presidents before him.

So far, Obama has made recess appointments 32 times, according to a Feb. 2013 analysis by the Congressional Research Service. Among the last four presidents, Ronald Reagan made the most recess appointments (232), followed by George W. Bush (171), Bill Clinton (139) and George H.W. Bush (78), who served only one term.  These include not only ones made between sessions of Congress, but ones during recesses within a session.

The case being argued at the high court stems from three recess appointments President Obama made in 2012 to the National Labor Relations Board —the kind of action that Republicans were trying to forestall by holding brief pro forma sessions during a long holiday break. When the NLRB ruled against a Washington state company in a labor dispute, the company sued, saying the recess appointments were improper.

When George W. Bush was president, Senate Democrats tried to use the same tactic of holding pro forma sessions in an effort to prevent use of recess appointments. Bush had made several controversial recess appointments, prompting Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid to schedule pro forma sessions in 2007 to try and head off possible recess appointments during the two-week Thanksgiving break in 2007.

Category: Daily Number

Topics: Barack Obama

  1. Photo of Bruce Drake

    is a Senior Editor at the Pew Research Center.

Leave a Comment

Or

All comments must follow the Pew Research comment policy and will be moderated before posting.

6 Comments

  1. Joy3 months ago

    Great info, however, I must point out that the typo in the graph above – it should say George H.W. Bush, not George W.H. Bush.

    Reply
  2. Jorge Miyares3 months ago

    It’s not the volume of recess appointments that was at issue, it was the deliberate and (as the court found) specious manipulation of the recess appointment process. This administration acts as if the Constitution – intent and letter – does not apply to them.

    Reply
    1. Mike Wright3 months ago

      The volume is certainly relevant. It would be interesting to know more about each recess appointment to determine, in light of the Court’s decision, which would have violated their ruling.

      Reply
    2. Brad4 weeks ago

      It is congress that is abusing the constitution by saying they are in session even though no one is there.

      Reply
  3. Randy Johnson6 months ago

    For Dennis and Erik

    Reply
  4. maya8 months ago

    you are the best you rock

    Reply