December 12, 2013

‘Merry Christmas’ or ‘Happy Holidays’?

46%

When asked about how stores should greet their customers over the holidays, 42% of Americans prefer “Merry Christmas,” 12% prefer “Happy Holidays” and 46% say it doesn’t matter.

Whether or not there is a “War on Christmas” in the United States, as some commentators believe, there’s plenty of discussion about the topic. In Texas earlier this week, for instance, a state legislator who sponsored a new law protecting traditional holiday greetings in public schools said he hoped other states would follow Texas’ example in standing “in defense of Christmas.”

Last December, the Pew Research Center asked Americans whether they prefer stores and businesses to greet their customers by saying “Merry Christmas,” or “less religious terms such as ‘Happy Holidays’ and ‘Season’s Greetings.’” The survey asked the question in two different ways to two different groups:

• A random half of respondents were asked to choose a preference between “Merry Christmas” and the less religious terms.
• The other half were asked a version that included those two options, then added “or doesn’t it matter to you?” at the end.

When the question is presented as a choice between “Merry Christmas” and the less religious terms, 57% pick “Merry Christmas” and 27% select the less religious terms. (In this instance, even without “it doesn’t matter” presented as an option, 15% volunteer that they don’t have a preference.)

But when “it doesn’t matter” is added as an option, it draws roughly the same amount of support as “Merry Christmas”; 42% say they prefer “Merry Christmas,” 12% prefer the less religious terms and 46% say it doesn’t matter. There has been almost no change since 2005, when we asked the same question.

In either case, there is a significant split between Republicans and Democrats on the question; Republicans strongly prefer the Christmas greeting. For example, when “it doesn’t matter” is included as an option, 63% of Republicans or those who lean Republican say they prefer “Merry Christmas,” while 5% choose “Season’s Greetings” or “Happy Holidays” and 32% say it doesn’t matter. Among Democrats or those who lean Democratic, 28% prefer “Merry Christmas,” 17% opt for the less religious terms and 55% say it doesn’t matter.

Category: Daily Number

Topics: Religious Beliefs and Practices

  1. is Assistant Editor at the Pew Research Center’s Religion & Public Life Project.

Leave a Comment

Or

All comments must follow the Pew Research comment policy and will be moderated before posting.

32 Comments

  1. James Vaughan7 months ago

    Since you rejected every comment I attempted to post here (and I attempted to post at least six, all of which respected your comment policy) and posted only ONE (“Merry Christmas to one and all!”), it would appear that you are indeed attempting to promote a certain point of view, all the while posing as an objective research group.

    Reply
  2. K.Flyer7 months ago

    Christmas is a time when most Christians around the world celebrate the birth of Christ their saviour. (some celebrate in January)
    Therefore the term Christmas should be used
    If someone feels offended at it, well thats their own insecure problem.
    All religions and faiths have their own time of major celebration, should they all be told to use the term “Happy Holiday” if in public, I think not. Because for each it is not a “Holiday” it is a time of celebration and contemplation of their beliefs and faith so why can people not allow it to be just that, including Christmas.

    Reply
    1. J.Hyres7 months ago

      Spot on!

      Reply
  3. Dan Nietzsche7 months ago

    I ask Pew Research Center to conduct a survey among Americans whether they prefer
    Happy Hanukkah or Happy Holidays!

    Reply
  4. Cody7 months ago

    I just say Happy Holidays because a “holiday” to me means no work, kicking up feet, relaxing, having fun. I don’t even think about whether or not they are celebrating Christmas or not — I just and wishing them happy times away from work.

    Why do people chose to be offended at *everything*?

    “Yooou didn’t say Christmas so I’m going to berate you.”
    “Yoooou said Christmas so that means you are putting down my religion!”

    It is ok, people. It will be ok.

    Reply
  5. SARNO687 months ago

    Christmas: TO BOATS 48……

    Christmas, as we celebrate it today, is mixed with both Christian and pagan elements. For instance, in paganism, the 21st of December is the birthday or renewal of the �Sun God,� as well as the Winter Solstice. Pagans were well aware of the sun cycles and seasons, as it was the governing factor of their religion by and large. The 21st of December was important to pagans because it marked the point in the year where the days would begin to get longer, in terms of the duration of time that the sun would be out. This pagan holiday, called �Saturnalia� was celebrated with an extreme amount of generosity and general merriment among everyone. Gifts were exchanged with neighbors and evergreen trees were decorated and danced around in celebration of nature and the perpetuation of life. All was made possible, according to paganism, by the Sun, and his return (on December 21st of each year), marked the promise of a new year. Later, when the Roman church attempts to unite pagans with Christianity, the attempt proves futile. Since they cannot stamp out the holiday entirely, the Roman church changes the date of the celebration and assigns new Christian meaning to it, designating it the birth of Jesus Christ rather than the birth or return of the Sun god. This was done in by the Roman church with hopes to make the transition from paganism to Christianity smooth. There is significant evidence that Jesus was not born in December at all, as the Bible specifically states that Mary and Joseph traveled to Bethlehem during tax season which would have been during a warmer part of the year, namely, late summer, early fall.

    In order to account for the pagan rituals that were still practiced on the new �Christian� holiday, the Roman church assigned Christian meaning to the pagan rituals of gift giving and generosity. The gift exchange became associated with the three wise-men that presented Jesus with gifts after his birth. Clearly, giving offerings to Jesus the son of God is much different than giving gifts to each other; however, this allowed the church to accept the gift exchange that continued, even after they banned the pagan holiday. In fact, the two holidays became so intertwined, that the word Christmas actually derives from the words �Christ� (Christian) and �mass� (meaning a pagan ritual or rite).

    Reply
  6. James Vaughan8 months ago

    Merry Christmas to one and all!

    Reply
  7. Chris D.8 months ago

    Honestly whether you believe in Jesus or Santa…. Merry Christmas! Why would this great holiday which brings everyone from all walks of life together offend anyone. Guys this is the United States of America! Key word: UNITED. We all stand for one another’s beliefs and must respect all people from all cultures and backgrounds. Its in our constitution and its what separates us from the rest of the world! I remember being in elementary school and celebrating all customs and traditions during this time of the year. We drew Christmas Trees and Minoras, sang Christmas songs and spun driedels. It was fantastic! I want my kids to have the same experience and learn about all cultural traditions during this time of togetherness and joy. Trying vale Christmas from the majority is not my idea of fairness or equality. Lets please stop trying to please people that keep trying to divide us and remember what this time of the year is really about. MERRY CHRISTMAS, HAPPY RAMADAN, & HAPPY CHANUKAH!

    Reply
  8. Barry Hollander8 months ago

    I have never, in my life, ever said “Happy Holidays” to anyone. It’s meaningless, pseudo-sensitive, politically correct drivel. Say something with meaning, or don’t say anything at all.

    Reply
    1. Alison7 months ago

      And it was commonly used — along with “Season’s Greetings” as long ago as on Victorian-era greeting cards. Apparently being “politically correct” is old-school behavior.

      Reply
    2. J.Hyres7 months ago

      Right on!

      Reply
    3. J.Hyres7 months ago

      I totally agree with your opinion! Enough of this PC BS!

      Reply
  9. Roslyn Ross8 months ago

    Only in America! The rest of the world, including countries where Christianity is a minor religion, have no problem with Merry Christmas. Why does the US? It isn’t a holiday, it is Christmas. Well, Americans get far less holidays than anyone else and other nations use Christmas as a long seasonal holiday, but the season is Christmas.

    Ramadan was ages ago, Deepavali and Hannuka are long gone by December, it is Christmas! Everyone calls it Christmas. Except in the US. Why this paranoia? It is Christmas in Hindu India; Christmas in Moslem Indonesia; Christmas for everyone but Americans. Bizarre.

    And the irony is that the US is the most religious of all developed nations and the religion is Christianity. Although Christmas is now as much secular as anything else and it is the one universal celebration because of that.

    Merry Christmas does no harm. Happy Holidays is ridiculous and found only in America.

    Reply
    1. Karen Wickersham7 months ago

      Christmas doesn’t offend anyone…it’s the self-righteous, “righteously angry” low–information nuts that insist people say “Merry Christmas” because it represents THEIR personal beliefs (and is a great way for them to bully others) that is offensive to rational people.

      Many of us who used to say “Merry Christmas” (whether or not we were “Christian” enough for the fundies), now prefer “Happy Holidays” because we don’t want to be seen as self-righteous
      a$&!?-holes. Thank you Bill O’ and Caribou Barbie for stirring up controversy where there really is none. Rational Americans didn’t start this fight. “Happy Holidays” and “Season’s Greetings” have been around since the first Christmas card…it really can’t be accurately considered a sign of “modern political correctness”.

      “Happy Holidays” covers Christmas, other religious holidays and New Years, so is quite accurate. It’s also a kind greeting. Who could have a problem with that? Oh yeah, those who insist that everyone else believe and communicate the way they do. I like to refer to them as the Modern American Taliban, or Neo-Birchers.

      Reply
  10. Dave Seventytwo8 months ago

    As Hillary would say, “what difference does it make.”

    Reply
  11. IamJBart8 months ago

    No one bothered to get my views in this poll. If they had, I would say that I prefer “Merry Christmas” to “Happy Holidays”. Just what is the holiday we are celebrating at this time of year anyway, Kwanzaa? Do we buy each other Thanksgiving presents? No, it’s Christmas. Besides, holiday means holy-day, so when a store clerk says “Happy Holidays” to me, I simply respond, “Yes, Christmas is a Happy Holy-Day, isn’t it?”

    Reply
  12. Boats488 months ago

    Christmas is a “Christian” holiday. Merry Christmas is the appropriate greeting. It was never intended to be all inclusive. The fact that the holiday is celebrated on the pagan winter solstice was the early churches method of gaining converts. It worked! If you’re offended or shamed by the greeting, too bad! Convert to Christianity, you will not be offended further.

    Reply
  13. Pensieve8 months ago

    I am very religiously Christian. I send out religious Christmas card, have a manger scene in front of the house and so forth. That said, I can understand perfectly why store employees are instructed to say “Happy Holidays” unless a customer cues them otherwise. For one thing, the employee himself may not be Christian and may object to using the greeting. For another, many customers may not be Christian.

    Does the birth of Christ and all that it means hinge on what the checkout person at Target says?

    Reply
  14. John Clement8 months ago

    when someone says “happy holidays” I always ask, “which one, Arbor day? Patriots Day?”

    Reply
  15. Bob A8 months ago

    With a cheery “Happy Holidays”, one is being far more inclusive of various thoughts of people they address than narrowing a greeting to just one segment of society. It would seem that “Happy Holidays” is inclusive as opposed to being exclusive. The people who insist on being greeted with “Merry Christmas” want to impose their thinking on all of us due to their claim to have exclusive knowledge of their thinking to apply to all of us — and then require all of us to meet their standard over other standards?

    Reply
    1. Steve8 months ago

      I don’t think anyone is insisting on being greeted with a Merry Christmas, but you must admit it is a bit puzzling to be greeted with a Happy Holidays from someone wearing a Santa hat. Hmmm… why not just come out and say it.

      As far is being more inclusive by Happy Holidaying someone, I think that misses a huge point. …If I wish someone a Merry Christmas, and that person is not Christian, and am wishing that person a blessing from the center of my beliefs. It is not ignoring what that person is, but affirming what I am and believe. And the person should receive it in the spirit that it is given. I am wishing you a blessing according to my faith, and with the best of intentions.

      If a Muslim were to wish me a Happy Ramadan, or a Jew were to bless me with a Happy Hanukah, I would be thankful, and would thank them with a full heart.

      That is what living in a multi-cultural society is about: being open with your faith, standing out but respecting the man next to you, not dulling it down in the hopes of being inclusive.

      Reply
    2. Del8 months ago

      I’m not afraid to say Merry Christmas. I don’t think anyone should be offended. However, the holiday has been so commercialized and monetized that it’s original intent has been completely lost. I don’t see the slogans of ‘Happy Holidays’ as some conspiracy against Christianity. I don’t think people should feel insulted or that other’s ‘views are being forced on them.’ I see all of this as a natural result of of crass commercialism and divisive politics. Regardless of our various faiths, we are a generally a shallow people.

      Reply
    3. cj8 months ago

      Why are you being exclusive and imposing “Happy Holidays” on those who prefer “Merry Christmas”?

      I am always amused by individuals who claim they are being inclusive, but are so brainwashed by silly political correctness they do not realize how exclusive they are. YOU are imposing on others.

      Reply
  16. MG8 months ago

    As a non-believer, I choose to view “Merry Christmas” as just as generic and all inclusive as “Happy Holidays” these days. Christmas is now just a word that happens to contain a religious symbol’s title. Christmas celebrations are mostly secular. Think about the use of “Merry” in the greeting. There was nothing merry or jolly in the story of the mythical first Christmas. If people meant to convey a religious meaning, wouldn’t they say “Holy” or “Blessed”? Oh, and the same with Christmas carols. I embrace the joyous sounds and the sweet lullabies with the same enthusiasm as I do Beach Boys’ “Barbara Ann,” Guns and Roses’ “Sweet Child of Mine” and The Beatles’ “Michelle.” They’re ALL about [fictional] people I don’t know, nor care to worship.

    Reply
    1. Puzzlin8 months ago

      That’s a good way to put it. Many miss the elephant in the room thereby limit our freedom to imagine what we can never really imagine. The mystery which permeates everything we are or do is never certain and we’re all speculators. The only difference is for those foolish enough to proclaim things they can know nothing of, are there to constantly remind us why ultimately it is a mystery after all. Those who refuse to admit to their overwhelming incompetence in the face of this vast Universe (which we have just only begun to realize in any meaningful way) are incapable fools. Fools who race ahead to the “perfect answer” show us what we always are suspecting. Mostly that we know very little about this Universe. For those desperate enough through, as there has been through the ages will concoct an answer out of thin air, call it revelation, and worship it mindlessly. What a wholesale waste. History is littered with this crap.

      So, enjoy. Understand and revel in the mystery as it truly reveals and unfolds events before us to experience, Find some meaning in what your doing and dream big dreams.

      And Merry Christmas, have a wonderful holiday. I don’t believe any scant evidence Jesus ever existed but who am I to get in the way of anyone’s fantasy. Some fantasy is ok, I guess. I say Merry X-mas to be nice, that’s it. The cards I send are not religious, but more like Peace On Earth types, something I do believe in, but not because of religion.

      I find the root for morality in the golden rule which all religions high-jacked. But it’s from US for US. It’s why it existed before religion and will survive long after religion loses it’s influence in our lives. Reason will inevitably advance us to where we need to go. Religion is early development on the path to critical intelligence which finds it’s interest in evident reality, which as it is turning out, has a big story to tell. Bigger than we can imagine.

      Again, thanks, I need the different points of view to keep a balance. We rise above the din sometimes, just a little.

      Reply
      1. LifeandLiberty8 months ago

        Its nice that some people are experts at writing pure jibberish as Puzzlin is. Respecting how any individual chooses celebrate or worship our Creator or greet each other at this time of year is mostly what made and makes this country the greatest country to be born in and live in. If the documented proof through the writings of known historical individuals is not proof in and of its self that Jesus is who they say he was in their opinion than can we not also claim that anyone who lived before photography and or audio recordings also never existed?

        Reply
  17. Chet8 months ago

    It is still Merry Christmas to me and millions more.

    Reply
    1. Aaron8 months ago

      Exactly!

      The issue here is not what wording is best.

      The issue is how people are so debased and bent and bitter that they cannot even receive a wish for well-being and a good holiday without turning it into some sort of pernicious assault on their individuality or ethnicity or whatever.

      One commentor above:
      “The people who insist on being greeted with “Merry Christmas” want to impose their thinking on all of us due to their claim to have exclusive knowledge of their thinking to apply to all of us” Hmmmmm. OK then.

      For those of you who don’t live in a world where every person different from you is a hateful dangerous, aggressive racist blah blah blah who must be shamed and silenced, I wish for you a sweet, peaceful, and joyous Christmas.

      Those of you who feel that I just attacked you culture or your little vanity or whatever are welcome to have a BAD Christmas. I don’t care. If you are so bent that you can’t accept my good will, then it doesn’t really matter HOW you are greeted, does it?

      Incidentally, I am Jewish :D Cheers everyone

      Reply
    2. Pensieve8 months ago

      Absolutely! If you give a checkout person a clue, and he himself has no religious objections to it, he’d probably love to say, “Merry Christmas” back.

      Is it really so terrible, though, if stores figure they can’t assume “Merry Christmas” is an appropriate greeting for everyone who comes into their shop?

      Reply
      1. Aaron8 months ago

        Yes, I feel that it is really that terrible. It is terrible that in a would-be free society people continue to insist that they should be legally protected from hearing or seeing anything that doesn’t fit their own individual worldview.

        I am perplexed that there even needs to be a discussion about this. We all have the right to free speech, and each of us may disseminate our holiday greetings in the time and manner of our choosing, no matter who gets butthurt about it.

        This whole “my culture isn’t being respected, waaaaah” has gotten REALLY tired. I dislike that nonsense coming from my own community (Orth Jew), and I dislike it from every other, too.

        Reply
  18. zangomike8 months ago

    Jesus was born in the fall, September, 6 months after john the baptist. Dec 25 was the pagans winter solstice. Check with Catholic history and you will find this to be true. Thou shalt have no strange gods before me. Thank you.

    Reply
    1. Bill King8 months ago

      This is true. The shepherds don’t “tend their flocks” in Palestine in December any more than they do anywhere else in the winter. The Christmas myth was created to replace the Roman Saturnalia that Europeans had celebrated for more than a thousand years.

      Reply