July 10, 2014

A look at the damage governments inflict on religious property

Sanjian Church in China
The Sanjian Church in Wenzhou in China’s east coast province of Zhejiang is demolished on April 29, 2014, just before the completion of its construction. The left photo shows the start of demolition on April 28, and the right photo the debris left the following day. (Kyodo via AP Images.)

The Chinese government’s demolition of a large church in the city of Wenzhou in April and recent reports of other, similar demolitions drew attention to fears of persecution among Christians in that country. A new Pew Research Center analysis finds that such incidents are not isolated to China or Christians.

Since 2007, as part of a broader study on global restrictions on religion, we have collected data on religious property damage – including demolition of houses of worship, and the seizure of religious groups’ property and government raids of houses of worship that result in property damage. The data used here are a sub-set from the report, which also includes property restitution issues and seizure of religious literature. 

Religious Property Damage WorldwideOur analysis found that governments damaged the property of religious groups in 34 countries around the world in 2012 (the most recent year with available data). Though such actions were most common in the Middle East-North Africa region (in seven of 20 countries in that region), property was damaged by governments in every region of the world. Destruction of religious property was least prevalent in the Americas, where two countries, Venezuela and Cuba, of 35, saw destruction of religious property.

In the Asia–Pacific, governments damaged religious property in 16 of 50 countries in that region in 2012. For example, in Burma (Myanmar), authorities locked mosques used by the Rohingya Muslim minority ethnic group, preventing many people from holding Eid al-Fitr prayers to mark the end of the holy month of Ramadan.

Incidents of religious property damage ranged in severity, from widespread, systematic campaigns to isolated episodes. Three countries each had more than 100 incidents in 2012: China, Russia and Tajikistan, where the regional government of Khatlon closed more than 100 mosques, citing a lack of construction permits. Authorities said the closed mosques would be used as “schools, medical centers and other public facilities.” Fewer than 10 incidents of property damage occurred in 22 of the 34 countries with such incidents.

Many different religious groups were affected by government property damage somewhere in the world in 2012. In addition to the damage of Christian and Muslim religious property, a Jewish cemetery in Lebanon was destroyed as part of a road construction project. And in Pakistan, military forces demolished a Hindu temple in Karachi. Similarly, in the Banda Aceh, a city in Indonesia, the government ordered several Buddhist temples and Christian churches closed under pressure from a Muslim group.

Topics: Religion and Government, Restrictions on Religion

  1. is a Research Associate at the Pew Research Center's Religion & Public Life Project.

Leave a Comment

Or

All comments must follow the Pew Research comment policy and will be moderated before posting.

9 Comments

  1. Karen in FL4 months ago

    Very interesting. I don’t see this in international news. Any correlation between incidents of property damage by governments and human rights violations in those countries?

    Reply
  2. schm0e5 months ago

    Lest you think “it can’t happen here”, consider that in New York City, if a religious organization purchases a placard advertisement from the City – for example, on the subway – the lower portion of the poster, roughly 30% of the entire ad – will contain the City’s disclaimer of religion.

    The City government’s policy on this is a quantifiable and visible confiscation of private property, a 30% tax imposed by the City government on religious advertisements.

    Seems like nothing compared to piles of rubble where churches once stood, I suppose.

    But that’s how it begins.

    Reply
  3. Raghav Sharman5 months ago

    India is nowhere in the list; yet some pseudo-secular people, just to tarnish the country’s image, claim that minorities (especially Muslims) are very poorly treated. The Muslim country of Pakistan had a Hindu temple demolished, but the secular country of India, which is portrayed as Pakistan’s blood-enemy, and which is more than four times as large, has demolished not a single mosque or church in the last two decades. Indians, especially Hindus (being the majority), should be proud of this.

    Reply
    1. Franklin5 months ago

      Kudos to the spirit of “sarva-dharma-samabhav” (live and let live attitude) of Indians showing wide tolerance to all religions.

      Reply
    2. Noman5 months ago

      Well probably Babri Masjid was not a mosque right? Oh I forgot, what happened in Gujrat? Didn’t the secular hindu’s burnt muslims alive? Probably your memory is too bad.

      Reply
  4. suzy5 months ago

    This information fascinates me though I wish we could have seen a percentage of damage specific to various religious groups. (i.e. 20% muslim, 15% Christian, etc.)

    Reply
  5. Akos Tarkanyi5 months ago

    I have taken Nigeria, Libanon and Cyprus as “Muslim majority” countries into account. The latter one I counted so because I think that probably the “Northern-Cyprus Turkish Republic” was the one where the cases were registered. Even if I made a mistake in that it might slighly change the rates but the big picture I have described remains the same.

    Reply
    1. Jason4 months ago

      Nigeria is not a majority Muslim country. Any destruction there is probably not a government act but an act of violence from the majority religion in that particular area.

      Reply
  6. JohnnyFlew5 months ago

    Christians in the US better get ready because we will no be exempt from this kind of treatment. Pastors will be jailed for teaching from the Bible, church services will be monitored. It’s coming.

    Reply