February 6, 2017

Diversity welcomed in Australia, U.S. despite uncertainty over Muslim integration

The global surge of refugees in recent years has raised questions not only about border security and immediate aid to those fleeing persecution and conflict, but the challenge of countries settling and assimilating refugees from different cultures. These issues are in the news again in Australia, where a refugee resettlement agreement between the Turnbull government and the United States’ former Obama administration is making headlines.

Many of the refugees in question are from Muslim-majority countries such as Afghanistan, Iran and Iraq. Australians are divided as to whether Muslims in their country want to adopt Australian customs and way of life: 46% say no, while 42% say yes. Americans are evenly split on whether Muslims in the U.S. wish to assimilate, while Europeans are skeptical that Muslims will adopt the customs and traditions of the European countries they now call home.

More generally, half of Australians say that sharing the customs and traditions of the country is very important for anyone to be considered “truly” Australian. Similar shares of Americans (45%) and Europeans (median of 48%) agree that cultural traditions are a very important part of national identity.

In addition to shared culture, about seven-in-ten Australians (69%) and Americans (70%) say that in order to be considered a true national it is very important to speak English. Europeans are more emphatic on the issue of language: A median of 77% say facility in their country’s dominant language is core to national identity.

The perceived requirements of being a true Australian notwithstanding, the prevailing view (49%) among the Australian public is that growing cultural diversity makes their country a better place to live. By comparison, a majority of Americans (56%) agree that having an increasing number of people from many different races, ethnic groups and nationalities is a positive for the U.S. In Europe, however, a median of just 22% across 10 European countries surveyed say that growing diversity makes their countries a better place to live.

In Australia, as in most of Europe and the U.S., those on the political left are more willing than those on the right to say that growing diversity is a good thing for the country. The 28-percentage-point gap is very similar to the left-right gap found in the U.S.

Note: See here for topline results of our survey and methodology.

CORRECTION (April 2017): The topline accompanying this blog post has been updated to reflect a revised weight for the Netherlands data, which corrects the percentages for two regions. The changes due to this adjustment are very minor and do not materially change the analysis of the blog post. For a summary of changes, see here. For updated demographic figures for the Netherlands, please contact info@pewresearch.org.

Topics: Immigration, Muslim-Western Relations, Religion and Society, Immigration Attitudes, Immigration Trends, Religious Affiliation, Muslims and Islam, Migration, Muslim Americans

  1. Photo of Jacob Poushter

    is a senior researcher focusing on global attitudes at Pew Research Center.

2 Comments

  1. Anonymous6 months ago

    To combine the view of 10 Europeans countries is somewhat strange. I guess the view differs in Germany and in Poland for example.

    We must all remind ourselves while Europe has been taking in millions of refugees and also have been subject to terrorist attacks, Australia and the U.S have not. One would expect the view of Europeans changed after the massive numbers of asylum seekers the last few years.

  2. Anonymous6 months ago

    There is a vast psychological literature showing that most immigrants– including American Muslims– opt to adopt customs of the larger society while also maintaining some sense of distinctiveness through preservation of their own cultural traditions. Yet the wording of the question biases survey respondents toward seeing the acculturation process as a choice between “adopting customs” and “being distinct.” It is not surprising, then, that so few respondents chose the “both” option.