November 8, 2013

Quebec considers new restrictions on wearing religious symbols, clothing

Women with banners and Quebec flags march in downtown Montreal to demonstrate against the Charter of Values. (Credit: Oscar Aguirre/Demotix/Corbis)

Quebec’s governing party introduced legislation Thursday that would ban public employees from wearing “overt and conspicuous” religious garb, such as headscarves, yarmulkes, large crosses and turbans.

The so-called “Charter of Values” also would require all Canadians living in the province of Quebec to have their faces uncovered when they receive state-funded services, including health care and education. Several other countries have considered restrictions on religious attire, including France, which has banned full veils in public places and headscarves in schools.

The Quebec proposal already has sparked protests and political opposition. Much of the public debate over the charter has focused on the measure’s potential impact on immigrants and their religious beliefs and practices.

FT_quebec-religious-groupsWhy is this happening in Quebec? News accounts suggest that political motivations, Quebec’s traditional identity, women’s rights and a possible backlash against Muslim immigrants all are factors in the debate. Proponents of the restrictions on religious attire say they are necessary to preserve “the values of secularism and the religious neutrality of the state.” Opponents say they would infringe the freedom of religious minorities and immigrants, particularly Muslims.

The demographic trends underlying the debate are complex. The percentage of Muslims in Quebec’s population (3.1%) is about the same as the rest of Canada’s (3.2%), according to Statistics Canada’s National Household Survey. And Quebec actually has a smaller percentage of foreign-born residents than the rest of Canada does (13% in Quebec, 23% in the rest of Canada).

But the religious makeup of Quebec’s immigrants is somewhat different from the religious profile of immigrants across Canada. A larger share of immigrants in Quebec are Christian (59% vs. 53% in the rest of Canada). But more of Quebec’s immigrants also are Muslim (17% vs. 10% in the rest of Canada).

By comparison, in the United States, Pew Research Center data show that Christians make up a much larger share of immigrants (74%) than in either Quebec or in Canada as a whole, and Muslims make up a much smaller share (5%) of foreign-born U.S. residents. In France, by contrast, Muslims comprise more of the foreign-born population (46%) than Christians do (41%).

The proposed restrictions on religious attire in Quebec appear to face an uphill battle in the province’s legislative assembly. They are backed by the Parti Quebecois, which is Quebec’s governing party but has only a minority of seats in the legislature. Other political parties that comprise the majority of legislators do not back the measure as drafted. If the measure passes, according to news reports, it is likely to face a court challenge.

Topics: Religion and Society, Restrictions on Religion

  1. Photo of Phillip Connor

    is a Research Associate at the Pew Research Center’s Religion & Public Life Project.

Leave a Comment

Or

All comments must follow the Pew Research comment policy and will be moderated before posting.

2 Comments

  1. Pete9 months ago

    I live in Quebec and find your article very interesting. Like you said, it’s very unlikely to pass in Quebec’s legislature, but if it does the federal govt has promised to challenge it. Only, in our constitution, a province can override rulings of the federal govt and supreme court of Canada. Called the Not withstanding clause, and Quebec has used it before!

    Reply
  2. Martin9 months ago

    Not that I support the idea of religious controls, but this is what you get when the government has so much power and employs so many people.

    Private companies face competitive pressure to hire based on actual job related skills. Government bodies pay no price for discriminating against things like religion (which I’ll admit, I think the supporters of this bill have Muslim head wear in mind).

    Majorities using their numbers to control minorities is the predictable outcome of democracy.

    Reply