July 8, 2013

5 Facts about Republicans and immigration

Republicans are as likely as Democrats to say enactment of immigration bill is very important. Only about half of Republicans (50%) say it is extremely or very important that the president and Congress pass significant new immigration legislation this year. But that is little different from the shares of Democrats (53%) or independents (46%) who view enactment of an immigration bill as at least very important.

Republicans see benefits – as well as costs – from legalization. Our June survey found that a large majority of Republicans (70%) think it would be better for the U.S. economy if undocumented immigrants became legal workers. About as many (69%) said undocumented immigrants are “hard workers who should have an opportunity to stay” in the United States.” And fully 76% say it would be unrealistic to deport everyone in the country illegally.

Yet substantial percentages of Republicans also see potential downsides from granting undocumented immigrants legal status: 77% say it would encourage more people to come to the U.S. illegally and 68% think it would reward illegal behavior. Most also say legalization would drain government services (68%) and cost U.S. jobs (66%).

As many Republicans as Democrats say they’d vote for a law that allowed unauthorized immigrants to eventually become citizens provided that they first fulfill a list of requirements. A Gallup poll conducted June 15-16 found that 86% of Republicans – the same percentage as that of Democrats, said they would back legislation allowing immigrants living illegally in the U.S. to become citizens after a long waiting period if they paid taxes and a penalty, passed a criminal background check, and learned English. The New York Times noted that polls that describe the many requirements an unauthorized immigrant would have to satisfy before gaining citizenship find higher GOP support than polls that do not mention the requirements in detail, or at all.

Republicans aren’t sold on the political benefits from supporting immigration reform. Some leading Republicans have said the party’s future prospects are tied to support for immigration reform. Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush called immigration a “gateway issue” for both Hispanic and Asian voters in a recent op-ed in the Wall Street Journal.

But rank-and-file Republicans are dubious. Only about four-in-ten (39%) say GOP support for legalization would help the party in national elections, 20% say it would hurt the party and 38% say it would not make much difference.

On border security, timing is everything, but there are divisions within the Republican ranks. Republicans and Democrats are on opposite sides of the issue when it comes to whether securing U.S. borders must precede allowing undocumented immigrants to seek legal status. A majority (56%) of Republicans say improved border security must come first, while 60% of Democrats say providing a path to legal status can occur while border security is being beefed up.

However, some of the same divisions that have emerged among Republicans on Capitol Hill, are also on display on this issue.

Fully 67% of Tea Party Republicans say undocumented immigrants should only be able to apply for legal status after effective control over the border has been established. Among non-Tea Party Republicans only 47% express this view.

Topics: Immigration, Immigration Attitudes, Political Attitudes and Values, Unauthorized Immigration

  1. Photo of Carroll Doherty

    is Director of Political Research, Pew Research Center.

Leave a Comment

Or

All comments must follow the Pew Research comment policy and will be moderated before posting.

1 Comment

  1. Anushka1 year ago

    I have been hearing that even the temporary legal status should not be given because that would mean we are rewarding those who disobeyed the law ……

    But nobody speaks the truth which is :

    This crisis of millions in the shadow happened due to wrong from both sides – the undocumented crossing illegally AND us, for not being able to handle this when it started happening decades ago; for not being efficient in having a system that works or employees who lacked efficiency for letting it happen,

    and NOW having us to pay through our nose.

    So, with due respect, remember when you throw the blame on them and feel you are rewarding them,
    tell this to yourself: “we are having to pay for our own faults as well”.

    Reply