June 13, 2013

South Carolina valedictorian reignites debate on prayer in school

Earlier this month, the valedictorian at Liberty (S.C.) High School ripped up his prepared graduation speech, which had been approved by school officials, and instead recited the Lord’s Prayer at the public school’s graduation ceremony. According to CNN, Roy Costner IV said he was trying to make a statement that “taking prayer out of schools is the worst thing we could do.”

It has been more than 50 years since the Supreme Court ruled in Engel v. Vitale (1962) that school-sponsored prayer in public schools violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, and more than 20 years since the high court decided in Lee v. Weisman (1992) that public schools may not sponsor or promote prayer at graduation ceremonies. But as the incident in South Carolina illustrates, the controversy over prayer in school has not diminished.

A 2012 Pew Research Center poll found that 65% of Americans believe liberals have gone too far trying to keep religion out of schools and government. A smaller, but significant share (48%) think conservative Christians have gone too far to try to impose religious values on the country.

A majority of Americans disapprove of the Supreme Court’s stance on prayer in public schools, according to 2012 data from the General Social Survey, conducted by the National Opinion Research Center at the University of Chicago. Asked whether they approve or disapprove of the court’s ruling that no state or local government may require the reading of the Lord’s Prayer or Bible verses in public schools, roughly 39% say they approve and about 57% say they disapprove. Those percentages have stayed relatively steady since the early 1980s.

Costner’s fellow Southerners are among the strongest critics of the Supreme Court’s rulings on school prayer. More than seven-in-ten people (73%) living in the South say they disapprove of the high court’s decisions on the topic in the 2012 GSS. But many in Costner’s generation have a different view. Nationwide, about 56% of those ages 18-29 say they approve of the ban on school prayer – by far the highest share of any age group.


Americans are well-informed about the Supreme Court’s rulings on school prayer. Of the 41 questions that Pew Research asked in its 2010 Religious Knowledge Survey, the single question the largest number of people got right is whether the Supreme Court rulings allow teachers to lead public school classes in prayer. Nearly nine-in-ten respondents (89%) correctly answered that this is not allowed. But the survey also found that many people think constitutional restrictions on religion in public schools are stricter than they really are.  Only 36% of the respondents to the survey knew that public school teachers are allowed to teach comparative religion courses, and just 23% were aware that teachers can read from the Bible as an example of literature.

Topics: Education, Religion and Society

  1. Photo of Michael Lipka

    is a senior editor focusing on religion at Pew Research Center.


  1. daughterofzion4 years ago

    So proud of this young man!!! God should be first in our lives and we should never be ashamed of our faith. He is totally right about being respectful of others beliefs. As Christians, we love everyone and we don’t force others to believe as we do. We all are given a choice in life and what path we choose is up to us. We just love one another and live the best that we can with the Holy Spirit’s guidance. Thank-you for being obedient to God!!!
    May God continue to bless you and your family!!!!

    1. Christina4 years ago

      How is causing a scene by reciting a prayer that is germane to your faith not forcing your beliefs on others? What about the non-Christian kids in attendance whose memories of their high school graduation will now be marked by this guy’s actions?

      1. LogicGuru4 years ago

        How is it “forcing beliefs”? to those who don’t believe it’s just blather-blather-yap-yap-yap. Blathering and yapping, or listening to others blather and yap, doesn’t force anyone to believe. Personally, I love blathering and yapping and would like to see as much of it as possible–of all religions. Ritual and ritualized yapping is one of the good things in life!

  2. Carlos Sanchez4 years ago

    What is truly remarkable is the folks who approve of school prayer and religious influence of government are the same people who dispise theocratic regimes such as Iran. They do not see the hypocrisy, nor the subjugation of others beliefs or non-beliefs.

  3. Jenai Goss4 years ago

    I wish I’d done that! Or, rather, written a *meaningful* speech rather than follow the guidelines I was given. It makes no sense that my faith, being the driving factor behind my motivation to graduate early and succeed in school, etc, was the one thing that I couldn’t talk about.