May 24, 2013

On Memorial Day, public pride in veterans, but at a distance

As the nation prepares to celebrate Memorial Day, most Americans have feelings of pride in the soldiers who fought in America’s post-9/11 conflicts. But the public that will be observing the holiday is also one increasingly disconnected from the military and the wars it fought since 2001 compared to those who lived through the wars of 20th century.

About nine-in-ten (91%) Americans said in a 2011 survey that they felt proud of the soldiers who have served in the military in the post-9/11 era, and 76% said they had thanked someone in the military for serving.

But that appreciation comes against a backdrop of a widening military-civilian gap that was evident in a Pew Research Center survey of veterans and the general public conducted in 2011.

This growing gap has roots in a watershed event: the elimination of the draft in 1973 following the contentious years of the Vietnam War.

The reliance since then on a professional military and enlisted volunteers has meant that only about 0.5% of the American public has served on active duty at any given time in the period since 9/11. The public’s military participation was .8 % during the post-draft 1990-91 Gulf War, and its peak during the Vietnam years was 1.8%. More than 2% of Americans served in the Korean War and nearly 9% served in World War II.

In addition to the substantially smaller numbers who have served, generational shifts are also resulting in loosening the connections between the general public and the military.

More than three-quarters (77%) of adults 50 and over said in the 2011 survey that they had a spouse, parent, sibling or child who had served in the military. But that number falls to 57% of those ages 30 to 49, and the generation gap widens even more for the youngest adult, with just 33% of adults under 29 saying they had an immediate family member in the military.

A Gallup poll conducted in 1991 found that 60% of those surveyed had either served in combat in World War II, Korea or Vietnam, or had an immediate family member who did so.

One result is that half of the public said in the 2011 survey that the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq had little impact on their own lives.

Another outcome is that both the military and the general public agree that Americans don’t understand military life. More than eight-in-ten (84%) of post-9/11 veterans say the public does not understand well or at all the problems that those in the military face. That view is shared by 76% of pre-9/11 veterans and 71% of the public.

Majorities of Americans surveyed in 2011 did not think the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were worth fighting. But even the opposition to those wars, and the gap between the military and the public, did not undermine the level of appreciation Americans expressed for the soldiers.

Vietnam presented a different case. Conscription had brought the war closer to home and helped fuel widespread dissent and protests. A 1979 survey for the Veterans Administration found that 63% said the reception at home for Vietnam veterans was worse than that for veterans of earlier wars.

The post-9/11 veterans served at a time when the military has become the most respected institution in the nation, according to the 2011 survey. Veterans from earlier eras are mindful of this shift in public opinion. Among veterans who served before 9/11, 70% say that the American public has more respect for those who serve in the military now than it did at the time of their own service.

Bruce Drake is a Senior Editor at the Pew Research Center.

Topics: Wars and International Conflicts, Military and Veterans

  1. Photo of Bruce Drake

    is a senior editor at Pew Research Center.

1 Comment

  1. robert marshall3 years ago

    My grandfather was an Army psychiatrist who served from 1941-1961. My father was an Air Force navigator killed on active duty in 1959 when I was 6 months old. As a military dependent, my medical care was provided by the military, we shopped at the Post Exchange and Commissary. As a teen-ager, I used post facilities for accomplishing Boy Scout merit badge activities and base facilities to work on my car. I was unable to serve due to a medical issue with my eyes. I remember where I was (in college) when I heard about the disaster in the desert when the Iran Hostage Rescue Mission failed, and I was really bothered by the contempt I heard expressed for the military at that time. Military members worked long and hard to recover from the lows of the 1970’s post-Vietnam. It really bothers me that the heightened respect the American public holds for the military was purchased through two very long and painful wars that seemed to be fought with little thought and planning. It is ironic that Colin Powell was Secretary of State, but his President and Secretary of Defense placed little concern with answering the questions that the Powell Doctrine required answering before going to war:
    “The Powell Doctrine states that a list of questions all have to be answered affirmatively before military action is taken by the United States:
    Is a vital national security interest threatened?
    Do we have a clear attainable objective?
    Have the risks and costs been fully and frankly analyzed?
    Have all other non-violent policy means been fully exhausted?
    Is there a plausible exit strategy to avoid endless entanglement?
    Have the consequences of our action been fully considered?
    Is the action supported by the American people?
    Do we have genuine broad international support?”
    Indeed, it seemed that the President at that time merely wished for Saddam Hussein to be ousted and for the American people to go out and spend as normal.