March 13, 2015

Study finds racial, ethnic divide in attention to crime news

Crime consistently ranks as one of the most followed and discussed topics by the public, and it receives more attention in local news media than almost any other subject. A recent Pew Research Center report reinforces these findings but also suggests that certain groups of residents pay closer attention to local crime than others in the three cities studied. A difference that particularly stands out is between racial and ethnic groups.

A deep analysis of local news in Denver, Macon, Ga., and Sioux City, Iowa, finds that in each city at least three-in-ten people follow crime very closely and more than half of residents often discuss crime with others.

Blacks in Macon and Hispanics in Denver More Likely than Whites to Follow and Discuss Local CrimeInterest in crime, though, is not equal across all residents in these cities, as seen in Denver and Macon, where racial and ethnic subgroups were large enough to analyze.

In Denver, Hispanics (19% of the city’s population) follow crime news very closely at nearly twice the rate of whites, 49% versus 26%. And seven-in-ten Hispanics in Denver often discuss crime news, compared with 49% of whites.

In Macon, blacks (41% of the city’s residents) differ from whites in the amount of attention they devote to crime news to nearly the same degree. About six-in-ten blacks very closely follow crime news, compared with less than half (43%) of whites. And, while a vast majority of both blacks and whites discuss crime, blacks do so at higher rates (86% vs. 76%).

Demographic Differences in Who Follows and Discusses Local CrimeDifferences in attention to crime news also emerge across education and income lines, with the less wealthy and less educated being more likely to follow and discuss crime news. These findings show that race and ethnicity, income, and education are all prominent factors in who discusses and follows crime news. (It is important to note that these three demographic variables are related to each other: Blacks in Macon and Hispanics in Denver report lower levels of income and education.)

Differences between women and men are less pronounced. Both tend to follow crime at roughly the same rates, but in Denver and Sioux City, women are more likely to discuss the topic with others. Nearly two-thirds (64%) of women in Denver say they often discuss crime, compared with less than half of men (45%). And in Sioux City the gap is 74% to 64%. In Macon, however, which has the greatest attention to the topic overall, both men and women discuss crime at about the same rate.

There is little difference among other factors, such as age and level of civic engagement.

Topics: News Interest, News Media Trends, Race and Ethnicity

  1. Photo of Paul Hitlin

    is a senior researcher focusing on internet, science and technology at Pew Research Center.

  2. Photo of Katerina Eva Matsa

    is a senior researcher focusing on journalism research at Pew Research Center.

2 Comments

  1. Tom2 years ago

    Let’s have a “what if” conversation.
    What if local and national media outlets (print & digital) WOULD NOT comment on a criminal happening until indisputable facts were presented. Also in an ongoing dramatic happening all media cameras would not be allowed “at the scene” although personal cameras would be impossible to negate.
    WHAT IF society would enact a major major overhaul of its decorum and revert back to trusting duly elected authority. WOW! What a precept!
    Being in my 7th decade I am truley embarrassed at the actions of today’s society. Unfortunately the current administration in D.C. cannot be blamed for what today’s society is like – this has been coming on for a long time. If you can’t blame the government for the days ills, who can yoiu blame???
    As POGO said long long time ago “We have met the enemy and he is us’.

    1. Alan Shepard1 year ago

      It’s very rare I encounter a comment that I agree with online. I could not agree with what you’ve said more. I often wonder what it would take to guide and direct public opinion in the right direction, how far would you have to take something before there was an awakening. Our media is really good at highlighting a narrative but what does it say about cases in the book White Girl Bleed A Lot, what does it say about Sweden’s violent crime rate going up 300 percent and Rape going up 1,500 percent since allowing black Muslim immigration. It’s a “… Dilemma:…” of epic proportions.