April 24, 2014

Cameron’s ‘Christian country’: What the numbers say about religion in the United Kingdom

The United Kingdom “should be more confident about [its] status as a Christian country,” Prime Minister David Cameron wrote in a recent opinion piece published before Easter.

FT_14.04.23_UKreligionHis statement has since drawn strong opposition, including a letter to a British newspaper from a group of more than 50 scientists, writers and others. Cameron’s comments “foster alienation and division,” the letter says, asserting that they are also not true. “Surveys, polls and studies show that most of us as individuals are not Christian in our beliefs or our religious identities.”

Both may be correct, depending on the data source. By one definition, England, at least, is a Christian nation: The Church of England is the official state church of England. Looking at the religious affiliation of the population, however, a more complex picture emerges.

There are different ways to measure the U.K.’s religious makeup. A majority of the population identifies as Christian, according to 2011 census results. But some surveys, including the 2012 British Social Attitudes survey (which uses different question wording), find a lower level of affiliation with Christianity.

The 2011 census in England and Wales (home to more than 85% of the U.K.’s population) found that, in response to the question “What is your religion?” a majority (59%) of the population said Christian. Separate censuses were conducted in the same year with a different question – “What religion, religious denomination or body do you belong to?” – in Scotland, where 54% identified as Christian, and Northern Ireland, where a higher share (82%) said they are Christian. In each of the three cases, about 7% did not answer the question.

But in the 2012 British Social Attitudes survey – which surveyed people ages 15 and older in England, Wales and Scotland and asked “Do you regard yourself as belonging to any particular religion? If yes, which one?” – a much higher share (48%) said they have no religious affiliation. The survey found the Christian population was less than half (46%) of the total.

(The United States, by comparison, is more solidly Christian, with 73% identifying as such and one-in-five identifying with no religion, according to a 2012 Pew Research survey.)

While question wording likely plays a role in the significant differences between the U.K.’s censuses and surveys, there also may be other factors. For example, question order may affect results; the religion question on the England and Wales census followed a question about ethnicity, while the ethnicity question came after questions about religion in the British Social Attitudes survey. There also are differences in data collection methods, such as the census being conducted primarily online and on paper and the survey being conducted via face-to-face interviews.

Topics: Christians and Christianity, Western Europe

  1. is Editor at the Pew Research Center’s Religion & Public Life Project.

Leave a Comment

Or

All comments must follow the Pew Research comment policy and will be moderated before posting.

3 Comments

  1. MsColleen4 months ago

    Another possible skew to the findings:
    When people are asked by conversation to select one group over another, the inclination might be to easily go along with what is perceived as the majority. When people are asked to make a choice on paper/computer to actively select a group, the choice might reflect a greater lack of desire to actively choose a group over no group. Interesting sociological/psychological questions to investigate.

    Reply
  2. James4 months ago

    The ONS is an organisation supposedly composed of professional statisticians who understand bias, so I found it hard at the time (and still do) to understand why they put out such an obviously leading question. “What is your religion?” presumes that everyone has a religion, as if it’s like your height – “everyone has one, what’s yours?”
    I would be surprised if wording weren’t the dominant factor in explaining the different responses.

    Reply
    1. MsColleen4 months ago

      I suspect you are right, and that their staff has few sociologists or psychologists to investigate the wording of such questions to weed out leading questions that might bias the sample population.

      Reply