Chart of the Week: Many in the Americas say high joblessness can justify a coup
Coups d’etat have become a notably less common method of regime change since the end of the Cold War. According to the Center for Systemic Peace, which maintains extensive databases on various forms of armed conflict and political violence, there were just 13 coups worldwide between 2000 and 2012 (plus last year’s coup in Egypt), versus 21 since the 1990s. While most people would judge that an improvement, Vanderbilt University’s Latin American Public Opinion Project has found that, under the right circumstances, sizable shares of the population in several nations would countenance military takeovers of their countries.
The chart above summarizes the results for one of LAPOP’s coup-related questions from its most recent biennial AmericasBarometer survey, about whether high unemployment would justify a coup. The 2008 AmericasBarometer survey found that between 36.3% (Uruguay) and 71.2% (Guyana) said high levels of crime would justify a coup; in the 2010 survey, the percentage of people saying high levels of corruption would justify a coup ranged from 20.8% in Argentina to 58% in Belize. (The black dot on each bar represents the percentage of people in each country who say high unemployment would justify a coup. The grey band on either side of the dot represents the 95% confidence interval, which means that in 95 out of every 100 samples of the same size and type, the result would fall somewhere within the grey band.)
It may not be surprising that significant numbers of people in countries with histories of military intervention might see coups as a justifiable reaction to perceived failures in governance. Paraguay, Peru, Guatemala and El Salvador, for instance, each have experienced five successful coups since the end of World War II. But other results are harder to explain: Guyana has never experienced a coup or attempted a coup since independence in 1966, while Argentina has had seven (plus eight unsuccessful attempts) just since 1946.
Perhaps the most interesting finding: 6.2% of people in the U.S. (no coups or attempted coups in its 200+ year history) said high unemployment would justify one — the same percentage as in Haiti (six successful coups and seven unsuccessful attempts since 1946).
Category: Chart of the Week
Drew DeSilver is a Senior Writer at the Pew Research Center.